Numerous Narratives

Why We Blame? Cognitive Dissonance, Dehumanization, and the Making of a Scapegoat

Being a visible minority and Métis, I have had a deep interest from a very young age in why society and individuals in positions of power harbour such deep-seated hatred, dehumanizing beliefs, and a need for scapegoating, projection, and blame toward Indigenous and other visible minority peoples. To see how those mindsets develop, it helps to look at the psyche and its workings alongside the social structure.

In Carl Jung’s model of the human psyche, the "Shadow" is the psychological darkroom where we lock away the parts of ourselves we do not want to face, these include greed, cowardice, and immorality. Jung, theorized we take the easy way out to not harm our ego, we rely on projection, casting our own ignorant failings onto someone else. In fact, an entire society can and does engage in this collective projection, dumping common fears or doubts onto a vulnerable group, you get mass scapegoating.

To understand how this leaps from a cultural habit into an individual’s mindset, you have to look at the feedback loop between sociology and psychology. Sociologically, scapegoating acts as a pressure valve. When a society faces economic issues such as Germany in the 1920s, or rapid demographic shifts, institutions and people in power often redirect public anger by shifting blame onto marginalized communities rather than getting to the root of the problem. Once that narrative seeps into every corner of public life through laws, media, institutions, and everyday talk, individuals absorb it as common sense and somewhat part of the societal and individual identity.

That is where cognitive dissonance takes over inside the individual psyche. Most people want to believe they are fair, compassionate, and living in a just society.

When they witness or benefit from the mistreatment of another group, that reality collides with their self-image, creating psychological stress. To reduce that dissonance without having to confront ugly truths, people reach for dehumanization. It is much easier to mistreat people, or look away while others do, if you first strip away their humanity, intelligence, and capacity for real suffering. By painting a group as inherently threatening, inferior, or incompatible with society, people who scapegoat others protect their ego by believing their own story that cruelty is actually an acceptable societal norm.

Canadian history offers a clear, painful look at how this society-to-mindset pathway works in the real world. Long before modern immigration waves, colonial expansion relied on casting First Nations, Métis, and Inuit peoples as "obstacles" to colonial progress. By dehumanizing Indigenous peoples, settlers and the colonial government reduced cognitive dissonance of stealing land while claiming to uphold British colonial norms. That narrative of projection and scapegoating was used to justify land dispossession, the Métis scrip system, the Indian Act, residential schools, and ongoing systemic racism and discrimination causing inter-generational societal and psychological trauma on the targeted scapegoat group.

Similar cognitive dissonance was later used on other visible minorities. During economic recessions, Chinese and South Asian workers were blamed for taking jobs from white labourers, leading to punitive head taxes, and outright exclusion laws. During the Second World War, racial discrimination on Japanese Canadians, were stripped (from the government) of their fishing boats, houses, and businesses and forced into internment (incarceration) camps, devoid of moral grounding. In every case study, the scapegoating pattern is similar: society refuses to examine its own failures, in turn individuals feel justified in their shifting blame or scapegoating a marginalized person or group of people.

The great American writer, essayist, and civil rights activist, James Baldwin, captured the emotional root of this scapegoating to look inward in Notes of a Native Son, observing that people cling to their hatreds so stubbornly because they sense that without hate, they would have to face their pain.