Dostoevsky's Prophecy of Totalitarianism

"The most terrifying thing about dictators is that they love their victims, and their victims love them back." - Milan Kundera

"The totalitarian state strives for the total destruction of the human spirit, for it knows that without the spirit, the body will submit willingly." - Hannah Arendt

"Freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two make four. If that is granted, all else follows." - George Orwell

"The great strength of totalitarianism is that it can erode the distinction between truth and falsehood, making reality itself a tool of power." - Václav Havel

For the past 2 months I've been rereading some of my favourite literature, Russian literature, short stories and novels. And of course, one of my favourite authors is Dostoevsky...

He'd seen the shadow before it hit the floor. Dostoevsky was not a passive observer of history; he had stood in front of a firing squad while wearing a blindfold and felt the seconds that separated destruction from life drag on forever. When a man is stripped of all illusions, he learns the shape of human weakness from facing death head-on rather than from books. Later, he started to see the outlines of a new kind of power in the harsh environment of the Siberian labour camps, where men are reduced to the bare necessities of life.

The czars, who ruled by divine right, would not have been like this tyranny. Even as it prepared the most complex control apparatus the world had yet seen, it would arrive wrapped in a cozy, almost maternal rhetoric that spoke of justice, equality, and liberation. A power so all-encompassing that it could not only control a person's physical body but also enter their mind, change their soul, and persuade them to refer to the process as salvation.

Russia was already tilting by the middle of the 1800s. Materialism, atheism, and a shaky faith in scientific rationalism were all exerting pressure on the ancient pillars of religion, tradition, and moral law. Young intellectuals started discussing man in the salons and lecture halls as though he were a machine that could be programmed, improved, and, if needed, discarded. This was not progress in Dostoevsky's view. It was the gradual, nearly not noticeable building of a brand-new prison.

He realized a sinister reality: the need for meaning does not go away when faith in God wanes; rather, it changes. A totalitarian power does not show up in that void disguised as an old-fashioned tyrant. It comes as a freer. It communicates in terms of moral obligation and encouragement. It requires conformity for your benefit, not the ruler's. Its most harmful strength is found in this shift.

Dostoevsky gave life to this vision in Demons. The novel illustrates how sterile, abstract ideals can turn red with blood when they are given to zealots. The educated and enthusiastic revolutionaries had given up the house of religion to bow down before a new altar: ideology. The movement, their faith community, its leaders, and their high priests all adopted political authority as their creed. Its the victims served as evidence of its values.

Terror was more than just a tool for eliminating rivals. It served as a tool to mould the human spirit. Loyalty to the State and the Idea systematically replaced previous loyalty to family, faith, and conscience. This was the cultivation of faith that crushed reason itself, not merely conformity.The church's spiritual space would be taken over by the totalitarian state.

Dostoevsky predicted the last and most evil step: the happiness that totalitarianism could produce in addition to the suffering it would cause. Dissent would be viewed as unacceptable, and people would grow to love their chains and take pride in their submission. Praising the hand that tightened the leash, they would exchange the chaos of freedom for the ease of total control.

https://www.globalgreyebooks.com/fyodor-dostoevsky-books.html